Fr. Brian W. Harrison, O.S.

Perhaps the most effective rhetorical weapon currently being wielded in this campaign is an appeal to a supposed precedent, namely, the legalization of interracial marriage in the earlier civil rights struggle. Indeed, we are being bombarded with propaganda to the effect that opposition to “gay marriage” is a form of outrageous “bigotry”, just like racism. In a decision several years ago that prompted last year’s ‘Proposition 8’ referendum, the California Supreme Court reasoned that just as that State’s prohibition of black-white marriage was ruled discriminatory and unconstitutional back in 1948, so now its existing prohibition of same-sex marriage should be overturned for the same reason.