Fr. Brian W. Harrison, O.S.
With several states now having legalized same-sex marriage, we are faced by a constant stream of propaganda designed to persuade us that this revolutionary change in our ethical and social norms, and in the whole legally recognized nature of family life, is both morally imperative and historically inevitable.
Perhaps the most effective rhetorical weapon currently being wielded in this campaign is an appeal to a supposed precedent, namely, the legalization of interracial marriage in the earlier civil rights struggle. Indeed, we are being bombarded with propaganda to the effect that opposition to “gay marriage” is a form of outrageous “bigotry”, just like racism. In a decision several years ago that prompted last year’s ‘Proposition 8’ referendum, the California Supreme Court reasoned that just as that State’s prohibition of black-white marriage was ruled discriminatory and unconstitutional back in 1948, so now its existing prohibition of same-sex marriage should be overturned for the same reason.